### Description of Supplementary Material Here we provide our analysis scripts and a synthetic data set to reproduce our results. **Data Set** The data set was created with the R package [synthpop](https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/synthpop/index.html) ([Nowok et al., 2016](http://www.jstatsoft.org/v74/i11/)) and mirrors the statistic properties of the original data. It allows for explorative analyses by third parties, which we can test on the original data if requested ([data set](https://osf.io/uynsv/)). **Analysis Scripts** The scripts reproduce our results with some deviations (result for the prediction of sexual sadism by the ASF subscales is slightly different). - Confirmatory Factor Analysis was conducted in Mplus [Mplus-script](https://osf.io/hbw5d/). - We conducted the MANOVA in SPSS [SPSS-script](https://osf.io/9b3fw/). - The comparison of the correlations coefficents and mixed-model analyses were done in RStudio [R-script](https://osf.io/sua4r/). Do not hesitate to contact us if any questions arise!