Main content



Loading wiki pages...

Wiki Version:
We argue that despite the fact that there are collective predicates that show homogeneity, homogeneity can be reduced to distributivity (contra Kriz 2015): First, there is a principled way of distinguishing which collective predicates show homogeneity: collective achievements and states lack homogeneity, (1)-(2) while collective activities and accomplishments show homogeneity, (3)-(4): (1) The students elected a president. (collective achievement) (2) These books constitute a famous series. (collective state) (3) The boys performed *Hamlet *for an hour*.* (collective activity) (4) The girls built a raft. (collective accomplishment) The positive version of (1) can be true in a situation where only a subset of the students (not all the students) actually voted, as long as enough students voted for the election to be valid. No undefinideness ensues. (2) can be true in a situation where there is a famous series of 6 books; books 1-3 are famous, while books 4-6 are more obscure. (2) is true, and not undefined, even though not every sub-series within this larger series is famous. (3) and (4) though are undefined in situations where some of the boys did not participate in the performance of *Hamlet*, (3), or some of girls did not participate in the building of the raft, (4). Second, collective accomplishments and activities have been analyzed as being able to host a D operator in their structure, while this is not possible for collective states and achievements (Brisson 2003). Therefore, once we control for the aktionsart of a collective predicate, it emerges that the collective predicates that allow homogeneity are exactly those that can host a D operator. Therefore, homogeneity can be reduced to distributivity.
OSF does not support the use of Internet Explorer. For optimal performance, please switch to another browser.
This website relies on cookies to help provide a better user experience. By clicking Accept or continuing to use the site, you agree. For more information, see our Privacy Policy and information on cookie use.

Start managing your projects on the OSF today.

Free and easy to use, the Open Science Framework supports the entire research lifecycle: planning, execution, reporting, archiving, and discovery.