Process Models Require Process Measures: Unconfounding Operating
Principles and Operating Conditions
Jeffrey W. Sherman, University of California, Davis
Dual-process models are frequently mapped onto the distinction
between automatic and controlled processing. However, it is critical
that process models distinguish between operating principles and
operating conditions. Operating principles refer to the qualitative
nature of the proposed processes-the mechanisms through which the
processes transform inputs into outputs. In contrast, operating
conditions, such as features of automaticity and control, refer to
the conditions under which different processes operate. In this talk,
I will describe some of the negative consequences of confounding
operating principles and operating conditions, describe the
methodological challenges of unconfounding them, and will describe
techniques for achieving that goal. I conclude by arguing that it is
time to eliminate the automatic/controlled distinction as a
definitional component of dual-process models.
_______________________________________________________________